Best Vanilla Extract Substitutes in Rhubarb and Custard Fool
This recipe calls for 1 tsp vanilla extract. If you're out of vanilla extract or need to adapt the recipe, here are 4 tested substitutes - each with a quantity guide and notes on how it changes the dish.
About This Substitution
Role in this recipe: Flavour foundation in sweet baking
When you want a different vanilla format or intensity.
4 Substitutes for Vanilla Extract in Rhubarb and Custard Fool
1. Vanilla bean paste
Ratio: 1:1
Same flavour with added vanilla seeds - gives speckled appearance and slightly more intense flavour.
2. Vanilla pod (scraped seeds)
Ratio: 1 pod per 2 tsp extract
The most intense vanilla flavour possible - use the pod in milk infusions and custards.
3. Vanilla sugar
Ratio: Use half the amount of sugar as vanilla sugar, reduce other sugar
Less intense - useful in baking where you want subtle background vanilla without extra liquid.
4. Almond extract (half the amount)
Ratio: 1/2 the quantity
Completely different flavour - sweet and nutty. Works in some cakes and cookies but changes the flavour profile entirely.
View the Full Recipe
See the complete Rhubarb and Custard Fool recipe for British kitchens with gram measurements and °C temperatures.
Other Recipes Using Vanilla Extract
Want to understand why substitutions work?
Our Cook Like A Pro video course teaches the underlying techniques - so you can confidently adapt any vegan recipe to what's in your fridge.
Explore the course Back to recipe